Replica By the Fireplace and Vanilla Skin

What do they smell like?

Both are warm and sweet. Replica By the Fireplace smells of campfire smoke, warm spice and vanilla; Vanilla Skin smells of vanilla, burnt sugar and campfire smoke.

Replica By the Fireplacecampfire smoke · warm spice · vanilla · warm · sweet

Vanilla Skinvanilla · burnt sugar · campfire smoke · warm · sweet

Wearers who know both say

“There are plenty of other similar fragrances to try like 7 Virtues Vanilla Woods, Billie Eilish No. 1 and Replica By The Fireplace.”

Reddit comment, r/FemFragLab, 2024

Which lasts longest?

Vanilla Skin lasts longest: a work day.

Replica By the FireplaceHalf a work day 4–6 hours

Vanilla SkinA work day 6–9 hours

Which will others notice?

Replica By the Fireplace carries furthest: across a room.

Replica By the FireplaceAcross a room across a room

Vanilla SkinSomeone beside you arm’s length

When do they suit?

Replica By the Fireplace: date nights and special occasions, in winter; Vanilla Skin: every day, in fall and winter.

Replica By the FireplaceDate nightsSpecial occasionsWinter

Vanilla SkinEvery dayFallWinter

Which costs least to wear?

Replica By the Fireplace, at about 17¢ a spray. Vanilla Skin costs about the same.

Replica By the Fireplace17¢ a spray $170 for 100 ml

Vanilla Skin20¢ a spray $99 for 50 ml

Who do they suit?

Replica By the Fireplace suits men and women of any age; Vanilla Skin suits men and women of any age.

Replica By the FireplaceMen and women of any age

Vanilla SkinMen and women of any age