Vanilla 28 and Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 42

What do they smell like?

Both are sweet. Vanilla 28 smells of vanilla, burnt sugar and rum; Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 42 smells of bubblegum, juicy fruit and burnt sugar.

Vanilla 28vanilla · burnt sugar · rum · sweet

Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 42bubblegum · juicy fruit · burnt sugar · sweet · soft

Wearers who know both say

“I love Vanilla 28, and this one definitely shares some similarities with it.”

Reddit comment, r/FemFragLab, 2024 · 8 votes

Which lasts longest?

Both last longest: half a work day.

Vanilla 28Half a work day 4–6 hours

Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 42Half a work day 4–6 hours

Which will others notice?

Vanilla 28 carries furthest: someone beside you.

Vanilla 28Someone beside you arm’s length

Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 42Only up close close to the skin

When do they suit?

Vanilla 28: every day and date nights, in fall and winter; Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 42: every day, date nights and going out, in spring, summer and fall.

Vanilla 28Every dayDate nightsFallWinter

Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 42Every dayDate nightsGoing outSpringSummerFall

Which costs least to wear?

Vanilla 28, at about 15¢ a spray. Vanilla 28 costs about the same.

Vanilla 2815¢ a spray $150 for 100 ml

Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 4215¢ a spray $150 for 100 ml

Who do they suit?

Vanilla 28 suits older wearers; Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 42 suits younger women.

Vanilla 28Older wearers

Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar 42Younger women